/>
musicOMH
home / features / albums / live / classical / blog
Facebook Twitter
search:

Prom 45:
BBC Scottish SO/Volkov - Harvey, Messiaen, Varése

@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 19 August 2008
4 stars
by Simon Thomas

The second of Ilan Volkov and the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra's proms was a demanding but stimulating exploration of the relationship between music and sonic articulation. The Royal Albert Hall was turned into a huge sound chamber, with every combination of acoustic and electronic music represented, featuring Jonathan Harvey's new work, Messiaen's final composition and two pieces by the grand-daddy of them all, Edgard Varése.

An evening of three halves, this was a long and well-structured concert. Even a purely acoustic work like Messiaen's Concert ŕ quatre, finished after the composer's death by his wife Yvonne Loriod, was a reflection on sound. The composer's life-long obsession with bird-song exploded here in a positive aviary of very specific imitation.

In the case of Harvey's World Premiere, Speakings – for orchestra and live electronics, it was the faltering beginnings of human speech that underpinned the work, although as it progressed through a slightly long 30 minutes, it was music that won the day. His earlier sound tape, Mortuos plango, vivos voco – for eight-channel tape, conjured up by the IRCAM engineers in 1980, deals solely in sound but nods back to the musical world with snatches of a boy chorister juxtaposed against insistent bell-strokes whizzing round the auditorium with vivid depth.

As Speakings integrates live and recorded performance, the final work, Varése's Déserts breaks up the components, delivering units of each in succession, in one of the French composer's most exciting works. Like Mortuos, Varése's Poéme électronique, written for the Philips Pavilion at the 1958 Brussels World Fair, is purely electronic; fascinating on CD but much more vivid flung around the RAH's considerable sound system.

A further variant was provided with the opening work, Harvey's 1994 Tombeau de Messiaen – for piano and digital audio tape, which also combined acoustic and electronic but here involving just a single live instrument. So, every permutation seemed to be covered, offering insights into how technology and performers can work together or set each other off.

The merit of individual works was maybe disguised in the process but brought together in this way, they made a satisfying whole. With so much reliance on technology and predominance of solo performers in the first part – Cédric Tiberghien (piano), Emily Beynon (flute), Alexei Ogrintchouk (oboe) and Danjulo Ishizaka (cello) all splendid – conductor Ilan Volkov was in danger of melting into the background but there was always the sense of a firm hand on the rudder.

An enthralling exercise in listening.

Comments

latest from classical
    1. Vaudeville Theatre: Master Class
    2. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Bělohlávek
    3. Wigmore Hall: GĂĽra/Vignoles
    4. Royal Opera: Così fan tutte
    5. Wigmore Hall: Coote/Drake
    6. Queen Elizabeth Hall: London Sinfonietta/Rihm
    7. Royal Opera: Don Giovanni
    8. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Gourlay
    9. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Knussen
    10. Wigmore Hall: Retrospect Ensemble
    11. Belshazzar's Feast/Philharmonia Orchestra
    12. Royal Opera: Die Meistersinger von NĂĽrnberg
    13. Barbican Hall: LSO/Gardiner
    14. Barbican Hall: Academy of Ancient Music/Egarr
    15. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    16. The Met: Faust - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    17. St George's Church, Bloomsbury: Consortium5
    18. Queen Elizabeth Hall: Britten Sinfonia/Elder
    19. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    20. The Met: Rodelinda - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    21. Royal Festival Hall: LPO/Jurowski
    22. Glyndebourne on tour: Rinaldo
    23. Glyndebourne on tour: Don Pasquale
    24. Preview: Salzburg Festival 2012
    25. LSO St Luke's: Dumitrescu/Avram/Hyperion Ensemble
    26. Wigmore Hall: The Nash Ensemble/Holzmair
    27. Purcell Room: Written/Unwritten/London Sinfonietta
    28. ENO: Eugene Onegin