shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
classical: BBC Proms reviews
Prom 65:
Berliner Philharmoniker/Rattle - Brahms, Shostakovich
@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 3 September 2008
5 stars
Simon Rattle and the Berlin Philharmoniker deliver freshly-minted performances of two cornerstones of the symphonic repertoire – a superbly detailed rendition of Brahms' 3rd and a coruscating reading of Shostakovich's 10th.

Some critics have accused Rattle of forsaking the Berlin Phil's heritage – namely those works emanating from the German Romantic period but last night's concert would have quelled their fears as Rattle led the Berliners in a scrupulously detailed, wonderfully restrained yet evocative reading of Brahms' Third Symphony. It's certainly his most introspective symphony, and shortest, but Rattle's total involvement was evident from the first bars – the portentous opening theme given its due weight, and wonderfully articulated by the strings.

Much ink has been spilt by critics trying to explain the Berlin-sound, but suffice it to say the string tone is warm and opulent whilst the woodwind and brass playing has a glorious glow to it. Conductor and orchestra breathed as one, each was perfectly attentive to the other and it's hard to think of many conductors who could coax such an introspective, finely-detailed performance as this. In short it was a revelation.

Having said that, after the interval we were treated to an exceptional performance of Shostakovich's 10th Symphony – indeed I don't think I've experienced such a sensational reading, in the concert hall at least, of this magnificent work. It was evident from the barely audible opening theme that we were in for a musical treat and we weren't disappointed. Throughout the ensuing sixty minutes Rattle's grasp of the architecture of the piece was faultless, maintaining tension throughout the lengthy first movement and building the climaxes organically from the depths of the orchestra so when the players were allowed their heads, as in the sardonic second movement, the results were shattering.

The playing throughout was exemplary and the challenges that the composer throws at the woodwind and brass were met head on. It seems invidious to single out any particular players from this tightly-knit ensemble but Wenzel Fuchs' clarinet playing was mesmerising as was Radek Baborak's horn playing in the third movement. An unforgettable evening.

  share: 
Facebook | Digg | del.icio.us | more


2009 proms reviews
Prom 74:
Vienna Philharmonic / Mehta


Prom 73:
Vienna Philharmonic / Welser-M๖st


Prom 70:
Royal Philharmonic / Maxwell Davies / Walker


Prom 69:
Leipzig Gewandhaus / Chailly


Prom 65:
Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester / Nott


Prom 63:
BBC SO / Robertson


Prom 62:
Royal Concertgebouw / Jansons


Prom 58:
Netherlands Wind Ensemble / Vis


Prom 55:
BBC SO / Runnicles


Prom 53:
OAE / Norrington


Prom 50:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 48 & 49:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 46:
BBC SO / Bychkov


Prom 45:
Ukelele Orchestra of GB


Prom 43:
Philharmonia / Salonen


Prom 39:
BBC SO / Brabbins / Wigglesworth


Prom 36:
The Sixteen / Christophers


Prom 35:
BBC Concert Orchestra / Mackerras


Prom 31:
National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain / Petrenko


Prom 28:
BBC Philharmonic / Noseda


Prom 27:
London Sinfonietta / Atherton


Prom 20:
SCO / Nézet-Séguin


Prom 18:
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra / Nott


Prom 15:
BBC SO / Belohlávek


Prom 7:
OAE / Christie


Prom 5:
LSO / Haitink


Prom 4:
Concerto Copenhagen / Mortensen


Prom 2:
Gabrieli Consort & Players / McCreesh


Prom 1:
BBC SO / Belohlávek




BBC Proms





More BBC Proms reviews from 2008
now in classical


  opera and classical index...


musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2009 OMH