shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
classical: BBC Proms reviews
Prom 73:
BBC Symphony Orchestra/Brabbins - Vaughan Williams, Xenakis, Holst
@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 10 September 2008
5 stars
This was the most incredible Proms concert I've experienced. The programming was inspired, the performances were stellar and there was a little bit of controversy to boot. Vaughan Williams' Sinfonia Antartica begins with low, ominous sweeping - very subtle brass underpinning the orchestra, indicating that we're in for an eerie night.

Not knowing this work at all, the soprano soloist and choir came as a total shock to me. The ghostly choir was accompanied by a wind machine, which was surprisingly effective the first time round but by the third instalment was a little cheap-sounding. This sort of piece seems to work very well on just a single hearing, descriptive and atmospheric as it is. After the choir has haunted the orchestra, Martyn Brabbins cast ice over the hall with perilous, sinister music trickling out from muted xylophones and harps, like an iceberg drifting darkly in the night. A colossal gong is struck which acted like a false ending before the organ kicked in. It was much too loud, and so couldn't have been better. The (faintly comic by now) wind machine rounded up the work with a chill.

Xenakis contributed the next incredible wall of sound. The percussion for Pleiades took up a third of the floor space in front of the orchestra, leaving the Prommers crammed into the remaining space. Six young percussionists delivered almost relentless, disjointed, gorgeous and harassing noise on custom-made metal slabs. The audience (most must have come for The Planets) was clearly rattled, twitching, whispering and leaving in clusters throughout the performance. This brilliant racket continually poured into your ears, synchronising only to immediately de-synchronise.

This sort of complexity can be heard as either highly sophisticated or totally primitive (and is probably both) but it's not to everyone's taste. One man decided to voice his opinion with two very loud boos, but this only bolstered the Xenakis supporters. Enormous applause burst out at the end of every movement in direct opposition to that dim-witted gent, and at the end of the piece the performers 4-Mality and O Duo received standing ovations in pockets of the hall.

Each section was presented with a different shade of lighting, bottle green, followed by pink with orange and finally red. The materials being struck changed from metal to wood, to skins - producing incredibly beautiful textures in a clotted tangle of rhythms. One modified vibraphone seems to be changing pitch as it is struck, sometimes the whole ensemble sounds as if it were having its pitches electronically modified. The music continued to be amazing, but always in very unusual, uncompromising ways.

Holst's Planets rounded off the evening in electrifying style. Any aroma of cheese evaporated with Martyn Brabbins' sheer conviction, making this all-too-familiar music seem fresh, and another invisible choir was utterly sensational.

  share: 
Facebook | Digg | del.icio.us | more


2009 proms reviews
Prom 74:
Vienna Philharmonic / Mehta


Prom 73:
Vienna Philharmonic / Welser-Möst


Prom 70:
Royal Philharmonic / Maxwell Davies / Walker


Prom 69:
Leipzig Gewandhaus / Chailly


Prom 65:
Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester / Nott


Prom 63:
BBC SO / Robertson


Prom 62:
Royal Concertgebouw / Jansons


Prom 58:
Netherlands Wind Ensemble / Vis


Prom 55:
BBC SO / Runnicles


Prom 53:
OAE / Norrington


Prom 50:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 48 & 49:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 46:
BBC SO / Bychkov


Prom 45:
Ukelele Orchestra of GB


Prom 43:
Philharmonia / Salonen


Prom 39:
BBC SO / Brabbins / Wigglesworth


Prom 36:
The Sixteen / Christophers


Prom 35:
BBC Concert Orchestra / Mackerras


Prom 31:
National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain / Petrenko


Prom 28:
BBC Philharmonic / Noseda


Prom 27:
London Sinfonietta / Atherton


Prom 20:
SCO / Nézet-Séguin


Prom 18:
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra / Nott


Prom 15:
BBC SO / Belohlávek


Prom 7:
OAE / Christie


Prom 5:
LSO / Haitink


Prom 4:
Concerto Copenhagen / Mortensen


Prom 2:
Gabrieli Consort & Players / McCreesh


Prom 1:
BBC SO / Belohlávek




BBC Proms





More BBC Proms reviews from 2008
now in classical


  opera and classical index...


musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2009 OMH