/>
musicOMH
home / features / albums / live / classical / blog
Facebook Twitter
search:

Prom 28:
BBC Philharmonic/Noseda

@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 5 August 2009
4 stars
by Keith McDonnell

The BBC Philharmonic delivers a highly polished, deeply eloquent and ultimately shattering performance of Mahler's 6th Symphony under its Chief Conductor Gianandrea Noseda.

Given its length, at just over eighty minutes, it's more usual these days to encounter Mahler's 6th Symphony as the sole item on the programme but Prom 28 also included Stravinsky's Scènes de ballet and Mozart's Bassoon Concerto . Not only did this Prom prove to be good value for money, but it delivered an evening of music making of the highest quality.

The evening began with a performance of Stravinsky's Scènes de ballet which forms part of this year's exploration of all of Stravinsky's ballets. Embarking on such a project has its benefits and downfalls. Whilst it can be beneficial to hear all such works over a season, inevitably some of his ballet scores are not as good as others, and to my ears at least, Scènes de ballet does not compare with some of his stronger works for the stage. Nevertheless it was performed with precision and élan by the members of the BBC Philharmonic.

After the somewhat uninspiring Stravinsky, Karen Geoghegan was the delightful soloist in Mozart's Bassoon Concerto in B flat. The bassoon isn't the easiest instrument on the ear, so all credit to Ms Geoghegan for delivering such a mellifluous and spirited performance with some hair-raising cadenzas thrown in for good measure. Runner-up in the BBC Two series Classical Star and still at the Royal Academy of Music she evidently has a brilliant career ahead of her. I just hope her colleagues who cheered her on weren't also responsible for the moronic applause between movements. Will someone please put a stop to this?

After the interval the orchestra surpassed all expectations with a monumental performance of Mahler's 6th Symphony. Noseda inspired them to scale new heights and secured playing that was at once disciplined yet impassioned. The final movement, virtually a symphony in itself, left both the players and audience emotionally drained – the hammer blows of fate have never sounded more foreboding, which set the seal on an extraordinary evening of music making.

Comments

latest from classical
    1. Vaudeville Theatre: Master Class
    2. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Bělohlávek
    3. Wigmore Hall: Güra/Vignoles
    4. Royal Opera: Così fan tutte
    5. Wigmore Hall: Coote/Drake
    6. Queen Elizabeth Hall: London Sinfonietta/Rihm
    7. Royal Opera: Don Giovanni
    8. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Gourlay
    9. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Knussen
    10. Wigmore Hall: Retrospect Ensemble
    11. Belshazzar's Feast/Philharmonia Orchestra
    12. Royal Opera: Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg
    13. Barbican Hall: LSO/Gardiner
    14. Barbican Hall: Academy of Ancient Music/Egarr
    15. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    16. The Met: Faust - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    17. St George's Church, Bloomsbury: Consortium5
    18. Queen Elizabeth Hall: Britten Sinfonia/Elder
    19. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    20. The Met: Rodelinda - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    21. Royal Festival Hall: LPO/Jurowski
    22. Glyndebourne on tour: Rinaldo
    23. Glyndebourne on tour: Don Pasquale
    24. Preview: Salzburg Festival 2012
    25. LSO St Luke's: Dumitrescu/Avram/Hyperion Ensemble
    26. Wigmore Hall: The Nash Ensemble/Holzmair
    27. Purcell Room: Written/Unwritten/London Sinfonietta
    28. ENO: Eugene Onegin