/>
musicOMH
home / features / albums / live / classical / blog
Facebook Twitter
search:

Prom 30:
Sibelius - Symphony No 5; Tchaikovsky, Mahler

@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 5 August 2005
by Ben Hogwood

It was to be the stuff of dreams. Neeme Jarvi was sadly not well enough to conduct his Gothenburg forces at the Albert Hall, so responsibility fell to the young Venezuelan prodigy Gustavo Dudamel, making his Proms debut at the age of twenty four in front of an expectant audience.

Unfortunately nobody told the engineers. The familiar warning to switch off mobile phones had a sting in its tail, in the form of two notes of sonorous feedback. Once there, it just wouldn't go away!

"The Tubin has been replaced by Stockhausen!" chorused the Prommers, referring also to the unfortunate casualty of the evening, Tubin's Toccata. "Stockhausen isn't that nice!" came the response from the gallery. The two notes continued, the Gothenburgers patiently waiting on the platform. Prom director Nicholas Kenyon appeared on three occasions to thank us for our patience. Finally the problem was resolved, and the crazy notion of feedback at a classical music concert was put to bed.

Dudamel bounded on again, and began with Tchaikovsky's Francesca da Rimini. This is one of the composer's most personal utterances, and Dudamel threw himself into the challenge, wringing out the notes from the string players, coaxing a wonderfully controlled clarinet solo in the slower music. The tempest swirled and the conductor, who apparently had just five rehearsals to prepare, beamed appreciatively at the results. It was hard not to share his enthusiasm.

Sibelius' fifth symphony, as always, offered huge challenge. Having recorded it recently under Jarvi for Deutsche Grammophon, the orchestra had it completely under their fingertips, and indeed rarely glanced at the conductor as he once again strained every sinew. It will be interesting to see on record if they adopt the slowing down of the tempo before Sibelius' masterstroke, the doubling of the beat to lead the opening movement into the scherzo without a break. Here it became a touch hurried, but the tremolo strings were always evocative, in the finale too where they revealed an uncanny similarity to the opening work. Dudamel showed all his credentials as he brought the work to its mighty conclusion with the six huge chords. He fully deserved his ovation.

There was an ovation, too, for the radiant Anne Sofie von Otter, who held us captive for Mahler's Ruckert-Lieder. Succeeding where so many singers have failed, she effortlessly projected her voice over the arena, helped of course by Mahler's deft instrumentation but also by Dudamel's sensitive accompaniment. The fourth song, which translates as I Am Lost To The World, was pure delight, the hushed strings in awe of the singer, who intoned "Ich bin gestorben dem Weltgetummel, und ruh' in einem stillen Gebiet!" ("I am dead to the world's tumult, and repose in a tranquil domain"). After forty-five minutes of rather less tranquil feedback, this was pure bliss.

Comments

latest from classical
    1. Royal Opera: Le nozze di Figaro
    2. Vaudeville Theatre: Master Class
    3. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Bělohlávek
    4. Wigmore Hall: Güra/Vignoles
    5. Royal Opera: Così fan tutte
    6. Wigmore Hall: Coote/Drake
    7. Queen Elizabeth Hall: London Sinfonietta/Rihm
    8. Royal Opera: Don Giovanni
    9. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Gourlay
    10. Barbican Hall: BBCSO/Knussen
    11. Wigmore Hall: Retrospect Ensemble
    12. Belshazzar's Feast/Philharmonia Orchestra
    13. Royal Opera: Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg
    14. Barbican Hall: LSO/Gardiner
    15. Barbican Hall: Academy of Ancient Music/Egarr
    16. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    17. The Met: Faust - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    18. St George's Church, Bloomsbury: Consortium5
    19. Queen Elizabeth Hall: Britten Sinfonia/Elder
    20. Barbican Hall: LSO/Davis
    21. The Met: Rodelinda - Live Relay at the BFI IMAX
    22. Royal Festival Hall: LPO/Jurowski
    23. Glyndebourne on tour: Rinaldo
    24. Glyndebourne on tour: Don Pasquale
    25. Preview: Salzburg Festival 2012
    26. LSO St Luke's: Dumitrescu/Avram/Hyperion Ensemble
    27. Wigmore Hall: The Nash Ensemble/Holzmair
    28. Purcell Room: Written/Unwritten/London Sinfonietta