shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
classical: BBC Proms reviews
Prom 65:
Brahms - Symphony No 1; Lutoslawski - Concerto for Orchestra
@ Royal Albert Hall, London, 2 September 2005
Considering the Concertgebouw rank as one of the world's top orchestras it was disappointing to see a number of empty seats in the Albert Hall to greet their second Prom of the season. Maybe the apparent paucity of the programme had something to to do with it - just an hour and a quarter of music seemed relatively short shrift for a whole evening.

At which point the saying about quality and not quantity comes to mind, and we certainly had the former in abundance in an exciting performance of Lutoslawski's orchestral showpiece. The snappy folk melodies that open the Concerto for Orchestra were in evidence immediately from the four bodies of strings as they successively entered, with Mariss Jansons' broad arm gestures securing wonderful playing from the woodwind.

The clarity of the orchestra in the quieter music was breathtaking, but always musical rather than just for show. The percussion in particular were superb, taking centre stage at the end of the central 'night music' movement with a rapid volley of what sounded like distant gunfire, bringing the hairs up on the back of the neck.

The showy last movement Toccata came off well, too, after a Passacaglia launched in an impressive unison by double basses and harps, unusually sat together. As Jansons brought the piece to an emphatic conclusion the orchestra finished with a flourish, a stunning feat of ensemble.

The Brahms that followed was also extremely well played, but threw up a couple of interpretative issues. The grandeur of the first movement often seemed to be checked by the conductor, as if aware of a homage towards Beethoven. Certainly the master's influence came through more than ever, the sweep of the strings kept at arm's length. The third movement, too, could have done with more cut and thrust in its central section, Jansons again happy to keep the orchestra within their limits.

It all depends on how you view the piece of course, as to which approach suits you best, and we were nonetheless treated to exquisite woodwind playing in the middle two movements, from clarinet and oboe in particular, the oboe raised unusually high to project its lines. And when the finale arrived, so did a real sense of drama from Jansons, whose tempo choices proved spot on, giving the big tune all the room it deserved.

As a bonus we got two encores, a Brahms Hungarian Dance and the Farandole from Bizet's second L'Arlesienne Suite, both realised as showpieces by the orchestra, conducted with abandon by Jansons. It was easy to forgive him for not showing such freedom in the symphony, and even inspired some of the audience to clap along to the music - a sure sign of the quality of the music making.

  share: 
Facebook | Digg | del.icio.us | more

Orchestration:
Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra / Mariss Jansons


2009 proms reviews
Prom 74:
Vienna Philharmonic / Mehta


Prom 73:
Vienna Philharmonic / Welser-Möst


Prom 70:
Royal Philharmonic / Maxwell Davies / Walker


Prom 69:
Leipzig Gewandhaus / Chailly


Prom 65:
Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester / Nott


Prom 63:
BBC SO / Robertson


Prom 62:
Royal Concertgebouw / Jansons


Prom 58:
Netherlands Wind Ensemble / Vis


Prom 55:
BBC SO / Runnicles


Prom 53:
OAE / Norrington


Prom 50:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 48 & 49:
West-Eastern Divan / Barenboim


Prom 46:
BBC SO / Bychkov


Prom 45:
Ukelele Orchestra of GB


Prom 43:
Philharmonia / Salonen


Prom 39:
BBC SO / Brabbins / Wigglesworth


Prom 36:
The Sixteen / Christophers


Prom 35:
BBC Concert Orchestra / Mackerras


Prom 31:
National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain / Petrenko


Prom 28:
BBC Philharmonic / Noseda


Prom 27:
London Sinfonietta / Atherton


Prom 20:
SCO / Nézet-Séguin


Prom 18:
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra / Nott


Prom 15:
BBC SO / Belohlávek


Prom 7:
OAE / Christie


Prom 5:
LSO / Haitink


Prom 4:
Concerto Copenhagen / Mortensen


Prom 2:
Gabrieli Consort & Players / McCreesh


Prom 1:
BBC SO / Belohlávek




BBC Proms





More BBC Proms reviews from 2005
now in classical


  opera and classical index...


musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2009 OMH