shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
film: reviews
Dinosaur
Dinosaur

buy this title


cast list

D.B. Sweeney
Alfre Woodard
Ossie Davis
Max Casella
Samuel E. Wright
Julianna Margulies
Joan Plowright
Della Reese

directed by
Ralph Zondag
Eric Leighton

buy dvds

Dinosaur is a Dino-snore. Despite a budget of reportedly US$200 million and boasting some eye-popping visuals, Walt Disney's latest animated feature is a boring, lifeless feature that will probably have very little appeal to anyone old enough to spell the word "dinosaur".

The film is set approximately 65 million years ago during the Cretaceous period, late in the game for the dinosaur species. As the film opens, we witness the long journey of a large egg as it is picked from its mother's nest and transported to a far away island. It lands in the hands of a family of monkey-like creatures named Lemurs, led by the patriarch Yar (Ossie Davis). Despite his protests and fears of taking care of a meat-eater, Yar and his family take the foreign creature, an Iguanodon that will be known as Aladar, as one of their own family members (wouldn't Tarzan have been a better name?).

All seems like paradise for Aladar and his Lemur family for a while, that is until a massive meteor show nearly wipes everyone out. They do manage to escape, but their home is destroyed. So begins the long journey to find a new home, one that has the group meeting up with a herd of migrating dinosaurs.

In true Disney fashion, there are nice ones, a romantic interest for the film's hero and a jerk that challenges the hero and learns the hard way that he was wrong about Aladar all along. Aside from the arrogant one (who is actually the herd's leader), the group also encounters vicious raptors and carnotaurs (who are a variation on the Tyrannosaurus Rex) while they search for their new home.

All standard, all done before and done better. It doesn't take a brain surgeon or even a well-versed film viewer to pick out all of the other films, Disney or otherwise, that Dinosaur rips off. Be it Tarzan, The Lion King or The Land Before Time, the screenplay is the worst one attached to a Disney animated feature in a long, long time (yes, even lamer than Pocahontas).

The characters are underdeveloped and clichéd; the jokes are weak, the film's moral message is delivered with all the subtlety of a train wreck and the situations that comprise the plot are without any sort of motivation or energy. There are villains that lack a sense of menace, a love interest that never develops anything to make us believe that the two dinosaurs would fall in love with each other and a Lemur mating ritual that had my friend and I scratching our heads, wondering exactly what part of Walt Disney's frozen body the filmmakers were smoking when they came up with that sequence. Even the voice cast, which includes DB Sweeney, Julianna Margulies and Ossie Davis, can't do much to liven things up.

So, is there anything of worth in this marketing campaign disguised as a summer blockbuster? Well, there are the visuals. The blending of computer-animated dinosaurs and real-life backgrounds is quite an impressive accomplishment, and the meteor shower that nearly wipes out our heroes in the beginning of the film is almost worth the price of admission. However, the visuals (and a strong orchestral score by James Newton Howard) can only carry a film so far, and after about thirty minutes, that stink cloud of a plot begins to ruin even that.

Animated features from Disney Pictures, despite their massive waves of merchandising tie-ins and hype, usually deliver the goods when it comes right down to whether or not the films are worth all the sound and fury. Dinosaur is the first case where this is not the case. Several reviewers have suggested that hand-drawn animation may soon become extinct. I disagree. The only thing in danger of becoming extinct thanks to films like Dinosaur is quality filmmaking.

Share ('DiggThis')
from the archive
A Prophet
A Prophet
Top
Top Films of 2009
The Road
The Road


now in film
REVIEW: A thrilling remake of Troy Kennedy Martin's Edge Of Darkness

REVIEW: Brutality reaches new heights in Breathless

REVIEW: Director Jacques Audiard returns with A Prophet

REVIEW: Return of the Brit gangster flick in 44 Inch Chest

REVIEW: George Clooney stars as a harried traveler who takes stock of his life in Up In The Air

REVIEW: Viggo Mortensen faces a post-apocalyptic world in The Road

REVIEW: Three well-known musicians join forces in It Might Get Loud



related
NONE AVAILABLE



  more film reviews...


musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2009 OMH