/>
musicOMH
home | features | albums | tracks | live | classical | blog
Facebook Twitter
search:

Comment: The Camden Curmudgeon vs The Tipsters

The Camden Curmudgeon vs The Tipsters
Empire Of The Sun: BUY THIS OR YOU'RE A MUTANT.
Here, in the first of a possibly irregular series of rants, The Camden Curmudgeon (not his real name) rails against the start-of-the-year phenomenon that is the BBC Sound of the Year poll, the "tipsters" who make it and the consequences it has for the artists it features.

You can give the miserable sod what for over at the blog. Or you can agree with him. He's not a tipster, so he wouldn't want to tell you what to do...
No one likes being told what to do. It's inherent.

As a child, people tell you to go to bed. To eat up. To do your homework. As a teenager you find the same people giving you a new set of parameters to live your life by: don't have sex with that. Don't take that. Don't drink that. Don't smoke that. Don't pierce that.

Then, when you finally reach adulthood, expecting that after this 20-year slog the tables might finally get turned such that you can tell somebody else how to live their life, they're just not.

So as predispositions go, a propensity for despising people who tell you how to run your life is pretty much guaranteed.

Yet you can't flick through any sort of music publication without some smug bastard informing you exactly what you should be listening to.

It happens throughout the year, but it reaches an apex with the January rush triggered by the BBC's Sound of the Year "critics poll"; a post-festive period of column inches devoted to the bands who you must hear, with the none-too-subtle insinuation being if you don't do as you're told you're a mutant nobody whose ears should be forcibly removed with a rusty pair of shears.

Fuck that. Actually, fuck that twice. Firstly, because anyone who tells you you must do anything is a grade one cock with no friends, who would do well to avoid any sort of self-awareness course lest they find themselves to be such an insufferable bore that they have to spend the next 30 years crying themselves to sleep inside a padded cell. Secondly, because there are only two situations in life when I want tips: if I happen to find myself stranded at Epsom racecourse with no money, no ticket home and a dinner reservation with John McCririck, or if I'm lap dancing.

Well, I've got to eat somehow.

Maybe if these tips were in some way exciting or novel or even accurate, then they may have something in their favour, but they aren't. They are never leftfield, because that's risky for the demographics, and as risks aren't taken it's more boring than that fella from Keane giving a lecture on the origins of the word 'mundane'.

And as for accuracy, seven words: Joe. Lean. And. The. Jing. Jang. Jong. Yeah, people aren't (generally) stupid and can detect recycled crap, particularly when it's smeared all over their faces by someone repeatedly screaming at them how good this recycled crap is.

Hence now, it's come full circle. Bands tipped in the Sound of the Year poll are faced with the ultimate death knell, even those who're halfway decent. It's a harbinger of doom prancing excitedly across a burgeoning career announcing, in 20-foot neon letters: "I'm shit. And you're going to hate me."

Take White Lies. Three months ago we could have had a conversation about them. We could have pontificated wildly about whether they were a British Interpol with a fine line in natty Duran Duranisms who could quite possibly be brilliant. Now, having been battered about the head with tales of their general magnificence for months, I'd probably try to stab you with a pitchfork if you so much as whispered their name.

None of this was their fault. So the album didn't live up to what was predicted, but who was it who brought those expectations up to Dickensian levels? The tipsters. In that BBC Sound of the Year poll.

There are more casualties of the war of raised expectations. Little Boots; La Roux; Empire Of The Sun - without all the build up, they all could have quietly got on with the business of building themselves careers. Now, if they don't prove to be the Second Coming, and if they all don't revolutionise music by inventing a new note somewhere between doh and ray by next week, I'll be so angry that I'll have to spend all my time spewing vitriolic twaddle into the universe until someone, somewhere agrees with me. Maybe on Twitter. Yeah, that'll show 'em.

(Although, I reckon that even if I hadn't heard Empire Of The Sun, even if they had never picked up instruments, even if it was 2,000 years in the future and we'd all evolved to the point where music no longer existed and all sound travelled from mind to mind through the power of conscious thought, the album artwork alone would still be reason enough to hate them.)

So. Tipsters. Who'd have 'em?


  Agree? Disagree? Couldn't care less? Have your say at the blog.

Comments


Comments

NOW IN MUSIC
Field Music
INTERVIEW
Field Music

David Brewis on the band's latest album Plumb and side projects.
Errors
Q&A
Errors

Steev Livingstone on unexpected tweets and Mogwai connections.

MORE MUSIC FEATURES
recent interviews and features:
  • Q&A: Pulled Apart By Horses
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 13-19 February 2012
  • INTERVIEW: Field Music
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 6-12 February 2012
  • Q&A: Errors
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 30 January - 5 February 2012
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 23-29 January 2012
  • Q&A: Howler
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 16-22 January 2012
  • INTERVIEW: The Maccabees
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: 9-15 January 2012
  • FEATURE: Ones To Watch 2012: Part 5
  • FEATURE: Ones To Watch 2012: Part 4
  • FEATURE: Ones To Watch 2012: Part 3
  • FEATURE: Ones To Watch 2012: Part 2
  • FEATURE: Ones To Watch 2012: Part 1
  • INTERVIEW: Luke Haines
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews Of The Year 2011: Part 3
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews Of The Year 2011: Part 2
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews Of The Year 2011: Part 1
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: December 2011 (Part 2)
  • FEATURE: Track Reviews: December 2011 (Part 1)
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Complete List
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: The Top 3
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 10-4
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 20-11
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 30-21
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 40-31
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 40-31
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: Nos 50-41
  • musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2011: An Introduction
  • more features
    RELATED ARTICLES
    NONE AVAILABLE


      more music features...


    musicOMH
    about us
    contact
    copyright
    home
    elsewhere
    Twitter
    Facebook
    Mixcloud
    Soundcloud
    Last.fm

    © 1999-2012 OMH