Objectively, DOA is Foo Fighters by numbers. The loud-but-never-impolite guitars, Grohl's simple-but-effective voice and the blatant-but-fairly-memorable chorus are all present and correct, and combine to create a piece of music for those who like their rock to be a bit edgy but not sharp enough to hurt.

Having said that, therein also lie DOA's strengths for few other bands do this kind of thing better (though Ash did a pretty good imitate and supersede job with Meltdown). Far from being DOA, the Foo Fighters continue to tick over healthily.