shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
theatre: reviews
In Extremis
Shakespeare's Globe, London, 27 August - 7 October 2006
3 stars
In Extremis

cast list
Oliver Boot
Sally Bretton
Jack Laskey
William Mannering
Patrick Brennan

directed by
John Dove
The final play in Dominic Dromgoole's patchy first year as artistic director at the Globe tells the true story of the 12th century lovers Abelard and Heloise.

Written by Howard Brenton (of Romans in Britain infamy), In Extremis is set in Paris, around 1115. Peter Abelard (Oliver Boot), a philosopher and teacher, meets Heloise (Sally Bretton) the seventeen year old niece of a prominent canon of the church and falls for her, completely and dangerously. The pair carry on an affair, which eventually leads to Heloise giving birth to a son, Abelard is punished with castration and the two lovers are separated, ultimately both joining religious orders.

While the piece follows the path of other plays on this subject, using both Abelard's books and the series of surviving letters between the two as inspiration, In Extremis is never just a straightforward love story. Instead, Brenton early on introduces a triangle of conflicting ideas that examine the philosophical arguments that raged around that time. Like Brecht's The Life of Galileo (an excellent production of which is currently playing just down the river at the National Theatre) this plays examines the dangers inherent in attempting to discuss man's place in the world, especially when it runs contrary to church thinking.

Abelard, in his writing and teaching, attempted to apply Aristotelian logic to discussions about God; Brenton brings in Bernard of Clairvaux (Jack Laskey), a Cistercian abbot, as the third side of the triangle. Bernard is a mystic who preaches that denial of the individual is the true path to a spiritual connection with God, while Abelard maintains that only through the application logic can we know God better - sowing the seeds of individualism.

Throughout the play, as the two lovers meet and fall in love, and are then torn away from one another and forced to begin new lives, this argument of spiritualism versus individualism forms the underpinning of the story. Laskey portrays Bernard as a zealot, bordering on insanity. Conversely Boot's Abelard is often arrogant and is terribly egotistical, reveling in the celebrity of being the philosopher of the moment.

Heloise (played winningly by Sally Bretton) bridges the gap between the two; she is a devotee of Abelard's, suggesting at one point that they are 'philosophical warriors'. However, unlike Abelard, even when she becomes a nun she refuses to dismiss the love she felt for him to a mistake, or a sin. Instead she argues that neither cool logic nor rabid spiritualism can bring God closer to man, only earthly love, passion and intellect can do so.

In addition to the three excellent central performances, William Mannering and Patrick Brennan offer some necessary light relief. My only criticism would be that, as in many of the productions at the Globe this year, the play at times lurches too close to pantomime - perhaps forgivable given the nature of the space and tourist-heavy audience who attend the Globe - but it often undermines the drama on stage. Furthermore, Brenton's concentration on philosophical discussion sometimes threatens to get in the way of the emotional power of this famous love story.

  share: 
Facebook | Digg | del.icio.us | more
from the archive
The Winter's Tale
The Winter's Tale
Mark Ravenhill
Mark Ravenhill
Edinburgh Fringe 2009
Edinburgh Fringe 2009



latest UK theatre reviews:
Follow, Finborough Theatre, London
Audience/Mountain Hotel, Orange Tree, Richmond
To Be Straight With You, National, London
Rue Magique, King's Head, London
The Dying of Today, Arcola Theatre, London
Blowing Whistles, Leicester Square, London
Faces in the Crowd, Royal Court, London
Knock Against My Heart, Birmingham Rep

latest new york theatre reviews:
The Grand Inquisitor, NY Theatre Workshop
The Language of Trees, Black Box Theatre
Romantic Poetry, City Centre
Love Child, 59E59 Theatre
Illyria, Hudson Guild Theatre
Speed-the-Plow, Ethel Barrymore Theatre
Capture Now, Theatres at 45 Bleecker Street

theatre features:
Interview: Adrian Sutton
Feature: First Look Festival
Q & A: Nicholas Burns
Preview: Off-Broadway Theatre Autumn 2008

cast recordings:
Jason Robert Brown's 13
Little Fish
Gypsy

more theatre reviews:
Piaf, Vaudeville Theatre, London
Oedipus, National Theatre, London
Aphasiadisiac, Lilian Baylis Studio, London
Overspill, Soho Theatre, London
A Disappearing Number, Barbican, London
The Brothers Size, Young Vic, London
Mariinsky Ballet, Sadler's Wells, London
La Clique, Hippodrome, London
NOW IN THEATRE
OFF WEST END: Six hours of Shakespeeare - in Ductch - in Roman Tragedies at the Barbican

WEST END: Ben Whishaw stars in Mike Bartlett's new play, Cock, at the Royal Court

OFF WEST END: Told by an Idiot's The Fahrenheit Twins at the Barbican

OFF WEST END: The Orange Tree revives Nigel Dennis' satirical The Making of Moo

NEW YORK: The Actors' Company revival of Sidney Howard's The Late Christopher Bean

NEW YORK: Playwright Jordan Seavey makes a splash with Children at Play

OFF WEST END: Becky Prestwich's new play, Letting in Air, at the Old Red Lion

RELATED ARTICLES
THEATRE:
The Comedy of Errors

THEATRE:
Under the Black Flag

THEATRE:
Antony & Cleopatra

THEATRE:
Titus Andronicus

THEATRE:
Coriolanus

external
Shakespeare's Globe
across the theatre section
BLOG
Edinburgh Fringe
Daily updates from our theatre editor at the Festival
EDINBURGH REVIEW
Hugh Hughes in...360
@ the Pleasance
EDINBURGH REVIEW
Pythonesque
@ the Udderbelly
WEST END REVIEW
A Streetcar Named Desire
Rachel Weisz at the Donmar
elsewhere on musicOMH
BLOG
Arctic Monkeys: Humbug
A first listen to the new album by the Alex Turner and co
REVIEWS
BBC Proms
Ongoing coverage of the 115th season from the Royal Albert Hall
INTERVIEW
Wild Beasts
The Kendal boys talk about second album Two Dancers
FESTIVAL PREVIEW
Bestival
Kraftwerk headline Rob Da Bank's Isle Of Wight retreat
film - theatre - classical - music

  theatre index...


musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2009 OMH