Album Reviews

Clare Maguire – Light After Dark

(Polydor) UK release date: 28 February 2011

The last few years have seen a string of home grown female singers sneak their way onto the Radio 2 playlist and into middle England’s heart, from Florence to Adele via Duffy. But it was last year’s success story Ellie Goulding who revised the crossover template. At times reclaiming girl-pop for pop girls, with the elctro-fizz of Starry Eyed, and at other times making mum-friendly tracks, like her cover of Elton John‘s Your Song, there’s an Ellie for everyone. So it’s no surprise that the her brand of radio-friendly electro is the one the industry is looking to.

Clare Maguire’s gone one step better than most and enlisted Fraser T Smith, who worked on Goulding’s album, for her long-awaited debut. Shortlisted for the BBC’s Sound Of 2011 and signed to Polydor since 2008, she’s been an insider secret for some time. But her first record is something of a disappointment.

It starts off with an intriguingly promising one minute speaker-shaking, Annie Lennox-ish warble over an eerie, atmospheric backing. Before you have time to blink, the theme’s continued with the vampy, Patrick Wolfesque The Shield And The Sword. Against a clattering of soaring strings, Maguire’s voice is pure ’80s disco-drenched power ballad, with the guts of Florence Welch and the attitude of Bonnie Tyler. It’s a slap of bolshy, air punching freshness with the glittery, feel-goodness of Goulding. And it’s as good as Light After Dark gets.

The next track, The Last Dance, offers a few glimpses of her bold, retro approach, with wonderful thundering drums al la Hounds Of Love, and there are sneak-peaks of similar quirks throughout the record. The problem is that as soon as they appear they vanish, leaving a collection of frustratingly bland songs that are polished to within an inch of their lives. It’s almost worse than her being a female James Blunt; the potential is dangled before your ears before being snatched away.

The 23-year-old Brummie’s unlikely voice can’t fail to impress though, and Happiest Pretender offers moments of luscious, Kate Bush-esque breathy vocals, and single Ain’t Nobody, a rush of haunting powerballadery with a Celtic edge, really showcases what she can do.

The rest of the 13 track album sounds like a mix of Latvian Eurovision Song Contest entries and The X-Factor winners’ songs; an unmistakable, cringey ‘life affirming’ theme runs throughout, with the obligatory twinkling electro loops. It’s an unexpected debut that proves there is such a thing as too well produced; we await the album’s tour, when Maguire may finally be able to put her own stamp on things.

buy Clare Maguire MP3s or CDs
Spotify Clare Maguire on Spotify

More on Clare Maguire
Clare Maguire – Light After Dark